Check Out These Amazing Restaurants in St. Augustine

Blessed with sun-kissed beaches, charming historic streets, and a close-knit community spirit, St. Augustine is a delightful destination for vacationers. While you’re here, our St. Augustine beachfront rentals offer the perfect home-away-from-home experience, ensuring your stay is as comfortable as it can be. One of the joys of visiting our beautiful city is savoring the local cuisine. With countless St. Augustine restaurants, ranging from trendy beachfront spots to historic establishments, there’s something to satisfy every palate.

We’ve handpicked a few remarkable restaurants that embody the culinary scene of St. Augustine so let’s explore some of the best restaurants St. Augustine, FL, has to offer.

Sunset Grille

Located near our St. Augustine beachfront rentals, Sunset Grille is more than just a place to eat—it’s an experience that’s been cherished by residents and visitors alike since 1990 when Pete Darios and Mike Rosa transformed an old gas station into a beloved beachside restaurant. The Key West-style atmosphere creates a vibrant yet relaxing dining environment. The menu features award-winning chowders that are perfect during a coastal getaway. Another standout favorite is the datil chicken wings, which add a tangy twist that many find irresistible. For those with a hearty appetite, the baby-back ribs are a must-try. However, what truly sets Sunset Grille apart is not only the outstanding food but the family-like bond between the owners and staff. This familial care has fostered long-term relationships, ensuring that customers are greeted by familiar, friendly faces year after year. The welcoming atmosphere makes Sunset Grille a dining staple for anyone visiting our beachfront community.

Salt Life Food Shack

Directly across from the iconic St. Augustine Pier, Salt Life Food Shack offers a dining experience that epitomizes coastal living. From its expansive outdoor seating area, complete with a rooftop bar and shaded patio, to its visually captivating saltwater aquarium featured on Tanked, the ambiance is both laid-back and enchanting. A consistently top-rated destination, Salt Life Food Shack is renowned as one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine, Florida. The cuisine is a celebration of fresh seafood, with eclectic choices that cater to all tastes. The menu pairs perfectly with cocktails, enjoyed alongside live music that plays throughout the week on the patio. With the friendly staff and the unbeatable ocean views, every visit feels like a mini-vacation. Dine indoors to escape the heat, or relish the breezy outdoor comfort; either way, you’re in for a treat.

Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila

At the heart of St. Augustine’s storied past lies Casa Reina, a cherished landmark lovingly restored to its former grandeur. This beautiful establishment pays homage to its roots, both as a historical site and as a hub for delightful, authentic cuisine. Offering a fusion of Mexican, Latin American, and Florida Coastal flavors, Casa Reina is a testament to tradition and innovation. The menu boasts traditional dishes like authentic street tacos and enchiladas, but don’t overlook the unique signature creations like the Short Rib Chiles Rellenos and Tequila Lime Grouper. Designed to celebrate the local heritage, Casa Reina offers breathtaking waterfront views, contributing to a dining experience fit for royalty. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Casa Reina invites you to enjoy St. Augustine’s rich history paired with culinary excellence.

Old City House Restaurant

Located in the charming Old City House Inn Bed and Breakfast, the Old City House Restaurant is a delightful fusion of quaint ambiance and gourmet offerings. For over eight years, it has been cherished as one of St. Augustine’s best restaurants. With an inviting atmosphere that evokes the essence of this historic town, every meal here feels like a special occasion. Old City House Restaurant is admired for its carefully crafted menu, featuring upscale dishes such as the herb and garlic New Zealand rack of lamb and the grilled vegetable lasagna. The dining experience is enhanced by the exquisite presentation and superb customer service, ensuring visitors return time and again. Known for its Sunday brunch as well as regular lunch and dinner service, it is a beacon of fine-dining located in the heart of St. Augustine.

Prohibition Kitchen

For a dining adventure that transports you back in time, visit Prohibition Kitchen on St. George Street. This 1920s-themed pub offers an immersive historical ambiance alongside generous portions of locally sourced bar food, craft cocktails, and live music nightly. The vintage industrial décor, reclaimed from the original colonial structure, sets the stage for an unforgettable experience. Choose from cozy booths on the first floor or enjoy a meal on the balcony level with views of the stage and the longest bar in the city. Prohibition Kitchen is more than just a restaurant; it’s a lively celebration of fellowship and the prohibition era’s clandestine spirit. The seasonally inspired menu, combined with St. Augustine’s rich history, makes for an evening well spent.

Casa Benedetto’s Ristorante

Casa Benedetto’s is a haven for those who cherish authentic Sicilian cuisine prepared with love and tradition. Generations of recipes have been handed down, much like the hearty family gatherings that inspired them. The restaurant promises a memorable dining experience, focusing on fresh, scratch-made dishes that bring the warmth of an Italian family to every table. Each meal is a testament to culinary craftsmanship, from rice balls to clam sauce linguini. The homemade desserts, with roots in the original bakery owned by Grandpa Benedetto and Grandma Maria in Brooklyn, are a particular highlight. The rich flavors of tiramisu, cheesecake, and cannoli transport diners to another time. Casa Benedetto’s Ristorante is about more than just food; it’s about creating an atmosphere where guests feel cherished and at home.

Columbia Restaurant

Celebrating over a century of exquisite Spanish and Cuban cuisine, the Columbia Restaurant is a historic and cultural landmark. Located in the heart of St. Augustine, this establishment offers a sumptuous dining experience amidst lavishly decorated rooms. Family-operated since its inception, Columbia Restaurant is more than just a place to eat—it’s a celebration of heritage. The extensive menu, filled with traditional Spanish and Cuban dishes, is matched only by the restaurant’s stunning décor, featuring hand-painted tiles and a Spanish-style fountain. A visit to Columbia Restaurant is a journey through history and flavor, making it one of the must-visit dining spots in St. Augustine.

Beachside Diner

For a nostalgic dining experience with a contemporary twist, Beachside Diner is the place to be. Opened by seasoned restaurateur Andy Viola and later adopted by Alan Wollenschlaeger, this retro-inspired diner serves fresh breakfast all day and Southern-style comfort food with heartfelt hospitality. The diner’s charm and generous portions have made it a favorite among locals and visitors. Beachside Diner offers everything from made-to-order breakfast dishes to classic Southern cuisine, all prepared from scratch. Their commitment to quality and community ensures that every meal feels like a beloved tradition. Relax, enjoy the friendly atmosphere, and savor the delicious food that makes Beachside Diner a standout choice.

Book Your St. Augustine Rental with Saint Augustine Vacation Rentals

As you explore the culinary delights of St. Augustine, finding the perfect place to stay is just as important. At Saint Augustine Vacation Rentals, we are dedicated to providing you with a welcoming home in our beautiful oceanside community. Whether you choose a cozy St. Augustine rental or a stunning beachfront property, rest assured that your comfort and satisfaction are our top priorities. Let us help you create cherished memories in this enchanting city, where history, charm, and extraordinary cuisine come together. Welcome to the family.